THE ANSWER
What should we fix first, what should we protect, and what moved?
Players are glad about the gameplay and angry at the studio, so answer refunds in public first and let gameplay carry the next message.
Of 24,959 reviews, 75 percent carry none of the nine feelings. Most of those are plain complaints, mostly about the studio and publisher.
Fix first: anger sits in 22 percent of the 7,214 studio and publisher posts, against 9 percent elsewhere.
Post one public answer on refunds, with dates, and pin it where refund posts gather.
Team: Community team
We check: Anger share in studio and publisher posts, 22 percent of 7,214 now, and in refund posts, 30 percent of 788.
How this was reached
Anger is 22 percent of the 7,214 posts on studio and publisher and 9 percent elsewhere, 2.5 times as often (range 2.4 to 2.7).
The counter-argument and how it held:
Anger is the most common feeling, at 3,091 posts, so any big topic will carry plenty of it. It held: the comparison is against 9 percent elsewhere, so the common feeling is already counted. The side is 7,214 posts, and the range stays between 2.4 and 2.7.
Protect: joy sits in 37 percent of the 1,222 gameplay posts, 8.7 times the 4 percent elsewhere.
Make the next public message a gameplay release, and hold studio statements until one can sit beside it.
Team: Development team
We check: Joy share in gameplay posts, 37 percent of 1,222 now, against 4 percent elsewhere.
How this was reached
Joy is 37 percent of the 1,222 posts on gameplay and 4 percent elsewhere, 8.7 times as often (range 7.9 to 9.6).
The counter-argument and how it held:
Joy may simply be common, and gameplay may be a broad catch-all topic. It held: joy is 1,452 of 24,959 posts, so it is rare overall. Gameplay is 1,222 posts, a large side. Even the low end, 7.9 times, stands far above chance among 11 concentration pairs.
Protect: players who enjoy the game want more, with desire and joy on the same 160 posts, 4.1 times chance.
Tie each gameplay update to a named item from the early access promise.
Team: Development team
We check: Count of posts carrying both desire and joy, 160 at this read.
How this was reached
Desire and joy fire on the same post 160 times, 4.1 times as often as the two separate shares would give (range 3.4 to 4.9).
The counter-argument and how it held:
160 posts is a small side, and both feelings are uncommon. It held: the 4.1 times already accounts for each feeling's own share. The low end, 3.4 times, stays well above chance. Only 2 co-firing pairs were scanned. Use it to support F1, not as its own line.
Protect: the early access promise still draws desire, 7 percent of its 2,928 posts against 2 percent elsewhere.
Publish what remains of the early access promise, item by item, with a date for each.
Team: Studio leadership
We check: Desire share in early access promise posts, 7 percent of 2,928 now, against 2 percent elsewhere.
How this was reached
Desire is 7 percent of the 2,928 posts on early access promise and 2 percent elsewhere, 3.5 times as often (range 3.0 to 4.2).
The counter-argument and how it held:
Desire is rare, 671 posts in the whole window, so a small number of posts could make the 7 percent. It held: the side is 2,928 posts, and the low end of the range is still 3.0 times. It is the weakest kept finding. It should be read as a supporting point.
THE READING / KERBAL SPACE PROGRAM 2
Ask the reading.
THE STANDARD VIEWS